Looking at Alva Noe’s Book (2023) “Entanglement” (Part 10 of 24)
0114 Here is three-level interscope so far.

0115 What does speech2af entangle for early Homo sapiens?
Well, to start, there is a question as to when speech2bf is appropriate. Surely, rules must apply. Can one speak during daylight hours, or only when shadows reign? Plus, when is one allowed to speak the words of another’s hand-talk? It is so complicated, some sort of decision process must be entangled.

0116 The resolution yields the following three-level interscope for hand-speech talk. This way of talking that is practiced during the Upper Paleolithic, when humans adorned the walls of the caves in northern Spain and southern France, many millennia before “Spain” and “France” became labels for artifices called “nations”.

0117 On the content level, the normal context of hand-talk3a (structure3a) brings the actuality of the dyad, {what I regard as the referent2am [substantiates] a manual-brachial word-gesture2af} into relation with the potential of ‘Peirce’s natural sign-relations’1a (disposition1a).
0118 On the situation level, the normal context of speech3b (identity3a) brings the actuality of the dyad, {the voice adorning as a principle of unity2bm [substantiates] speech as the vocal companion to a hand-talk word2bf} into relation with the potential of ‘a power to adorn’1b (which is one of the adaptations of Homo sapiens).
0119 On the perspective level, the normal context of communal activity3c brings the dyadic actuality, {a decision process concerning when to speak and when to hand-talk2am [substantiates] cultural traditions that eventually lead to speech and hand talk to become two independent and complementary modes of talking2af} into relation with the potential of ‘figuring out who is supposed to speak (adorn) or hand-talk (that which is adorned)’1c.
0120 The author does not ideate why he brings up Paleolithic art right at the start of his book.
Surely there is a method to his madness.
A semiotic story of human evolution resides just below the surface of his discourse.
Homo sapiens practices hand-speech talk from the very start. Over the course of three-hundred thousand years, hand-speech talk evolves from a vocal adornment to hand-talk under circumstances where it is difficult to see to two complementary and independent modes of talking, where the mode is prescribed by cultural tradition.
0121 In section two of chapter one (S2C1), the author develops the idea of first-order and second-order entanglements. To me, these correspond to sensible construction (involving the content and situation levels) and social construction (involving all three levels), respectively.
The content and situation levels are ordered as habits, by the perspective level. The perspective level “resists” the “habitual expressions” of the content and situation levels. In a modern education setting, the teacher “resists” the “habitual expressions” of the students. In the process, the student learns proper civilized behavior and the teacher practices the art and philosophy of teaching.
0122 Chapter two (C2) is titled, “Domestic entanglements”.
Surely, in the above figure, culture and nature are “entangled”, because this nested form portrays a cognitive adaptation to the niche of triadic relations. Culture and nature are not “entangled” in the very narrow definition, where one form engages two matters, one originating and one entangled. They are not entangled by way of confounding. They are “entangled” in the way that the author portrays. Nature and culture cannot be teased apart.
0123 Here is an example.
The Australian aborigines still (sort of) practice hand-speech talk. By tradition, a recently widowed woman is not allowed to speak for one year. She may communicate only in hand-talk. During her period of mourning, hand-talk is first order for her. The communal tradition is second-order.
0124 The author describes the second-order looping down and “entangling” the first-order. The second-order reveals ourselves to ourselves. In this instance, a second-order decision process2cm substantiates a tradition2cf that implicitly issues a first order to the widow. She must literally perform her situation, by not engaging the speech2bf, which is fundamentally an adornment that virtually situates hand-talk2af.
0125 There are many implications.
0126 One cannot simply listen to the widow complain in spoken words while turning one’s face away from her. If she can only hand-talk, the listener has to look at her. She hand-talks gesture-words about this or that and the listener sees not only what she says, but her demeanor as well.
In a profound way, widows are alone. Civilized folk don’t want to look at people who are bereft. Yet here, in a world losing touch with the Lebenswelt that we evolved in, the timeless tradition says, “No, do not shut her out. Look at what she has to say. See her body dancing the pain of loss. See what her body has to say.”






















